Practices of antimicrobial usage and associated resistance emergence in
smallholder beef cattle production systems in Northern Nigeria: Drivers
and One Health challenge
Abstract
Increased animal intensification has led to increased antimicrobial
usage (AMU) with consequent antimicrobial resistance (AMR) development.
This study assess farmers’ practices regarding AMU in beef cattle farms,
explore pathways for AMR dissemination, establish risk status of AMU,
and determine residues presence. We hypothesized socio-economic factors
not to drive antimicrobial misuse and resistance emergence in beef
production systems. Cross-sectional study was conducted on randomly
selected beef farms in Northern Nigeria between 2018 and 2019. Traffic
Light model was used to assess farms’ AMU risk status. Disc Diffusion
Test was performed to detect residues in cattle urine. Descriptive and
multivariable logistic regressions analyses were performed at 95%
confidence level. Of 660 beef cattle farmers selected, 92.1% (n=608)
participated in the study. About 78.9% intensive and 76.6%
semi-intensive farmers do not followed instructions on antimicrobial
dosage. Also, 72.4% of intensive and 83.9.6% semi-intensive farmers do
not observed withdrawal period after AMU on animals. Majorities of
intensive (71.5%) and semi-intensive (53.2%) farmers used
antimicrobials as growth promoters on beef production. Significantly
used antimicrobials on beef cattle were: tetracyclines, sulfonamides,
and penicillin. Pathways for AMR spread from beef animals were:
consumption of contaminated meat (p=0.007); contacts with contaminated
animals and fomites (p<0.001); and contaminated manure and
aerosols in environment (p=0.003) Factors that significantly drive
antimicrobials misuse and resistance emergence were: inappropriate AMU
(OR=2.72; 95% CI:1.93-3.83), non-enforcement of laws (OR=2.98; 95%
CI:2.11-4.21), low education and expertise (OR=1.52; 95% CI:1.09-2.12),
and management system (OR=10.24; 95% CI:6.75-15.54). Traffic Light
model has shown 63.6% intensive and 57.63% semi-intensive farms to be
in Class 3 (Red risk) status. Antimicrobial residues were in 48.4%
intensively managed and 34.4% semi-intensive farms. The study revealed
low practices towards AMU in beef cattle productions. Adequate
sanitation and biosecurity, and application of ‘One Health’ will
mitigate AMR at animal-human-environment interface.