loading page

Demonstrating the impact of incivility in an obstetric emergency: An interventional simulation study.
  • +4
  • Hannah Pierce,
  • Jonathan Bone,
  • Elinor Carlisle,
  • Maria Darcy,
  • Lynn Grant,
  • Ganga Verma,
  • Alexandra Kermack
Hannah Pierce
Princess Anne Hospital

Corresponding Author:[email protected]

Author Profile
Jonathan Bone
University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust
Author Profile
Elinor Carlisle
Princess Anne Hospital
Author Profile
Maria Darcy
Princess Anne Hospital
Author Profile
Lynn Grant
University Hospitals Dorset NHS Foundation Trust
Author Profile
Ganga Verma
Princess Anne Hospital
Author Profile
Alexandra Kermack
Princess Anne Hospital
Author Profile

Abstract

Objective: To understand the effect of an uncivil environment on the performance of an obstetric team with a focus on non-technical skills, and to ascertain whether simulation training can be used to demonstrate the impact of incivility. Design: An interventional, simulation study. Setting: Wessex Deanery School of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (O&G), UK. Population or Sample: O&G trainees. Methods: Ethical approval was received from the University of Southampton Research Ethics Committee (81008). Following informed consent, twenty three trainees observed two simulated scenarios of the management of a postpartum haemorrhage (PPH) and completed a Team Emergency Assessment Measure (TEAM) questionnaire for each simulation. In the first scenario the anaesthetist was civil and in the second uncivil. ANOVA was used for statistical analysis, p values of <0.05 were considered statistically significant. Main Outcome Measures: TEAM observation questionnaire domains of leadership, teamwork and team management. Results: There was a significant reduction in the overall team performance in an uncivil environment compared to a civil one (p=0.006). The biggest differences in scores were observed in team morale (4.00/4.00 in the civil versus 2.22/4.00 in the uncivil simulation, p<0.001) and effective communication (4.00/4.00 in the civil versus 2.22/4.00 in the uncivil simulation, p<0.001). Conclusions: Incivility affects the ability of the multi-disciplinary team to effectively manage an obstetric emergency and simulation is an effective tool to demonstrate the impact of poor workplace behaviours.