To the Editor
Peanuts are one of the most common food allergens.1 In
Japan, 5.1% of all food allergy cases are peanut
allergies.2 Although oral food challenge (OFC) is the
gold standard to diagnose peanut allergy, severe reactions sometimes
occur.3
Recently, specific immunoglobulin E (sIgE) to peanut allergen components
can be measured. Arachis Hypogaea (Ara h) 2 is one of the peanut
allergen components, and sIgE levels to Ara h 2 could be a predictive
marker in diagnosing a peanut allergy.4 However,
predictive values were different between studies, because these values
depend on disease prevalence as well as patient age.5We have reported that a previous history of immediate reactions may
change the predictive decision point (PPV) of positive buckwheat
OFC.6 Similarly, one Australian study of 1-year-old
infants showed that a previous history of peanut reactions altered the
95% PPV of peanut sIgE for peanut allergy; however, no study has
evaluated the influence of the presence of a previous history of
immediate reactions on PPV of Ara h 2 sIgE and 5% PPV of peanut
sIgE.7 Here, we evaluated it in children.
This study retrospectively analyzed data from subjects aged
<18 years who underwent a 3 g peanut (containing 750 mg peanut
protein) OFC on admission between March 2010 and March 2016 at
Sagamihara National Hospital.
Overall, 128 patients, with a median age of 6.7 years, were assessed
(See Supplementary Figure S1, Patient Enrollment and Background
Characteristics and Supplementary Table S1). The median levels of peanut
sIgE and Ara h 2 sIgE were 9.7 kUA/L and 1.1
kUA/L, respectively. Of 128 patients, 49 patients (38%)
had a history of immediate reactions to peanuts, and 16 (12%) had a
history of anaphylaxis due to peanuts.
Among 128 patients, 50 patients (39 %) reacted and 18 patients (36%)
presented with an anaphylactic reaction during OFC. Statistically
significant differences were observed between patients with positive and
negative OFC results depending on whether they had a previous history of
immediate reactions to peanuts, a previous history of anaphylactic
reactions to peanuts, atopic dermatitis and total IgE level. Patients
with positive results had significantly higher levels of peanut sIgE
(11.4 vs 7.3 kUA/L, p = 0.038) and Ara h 2 sIgE
(9.84 vs 0.19 kUA/L, p < 0.001)
(Supplementary Table S2).
Multivariate analyses were performed with adjusting by three
statistically significant predictors for positive OFC results: age, a
previous history of immediate reactions to peanuts, and atopic
dermatitis (Supplementary Table S3). Peanut sIgE level (adjusted odds
ratio: 4.5, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.7–12.1, p =
0.002) and Ara h 2 sIgE level (adjusted odds ratio: 8.3, 95% CI:
3.7–18.3, p < 0.001) were significant risk factors for
positive OFC results. The areas under the peanut sIgE and Ara h 2 sIgE
receiver operating characteristic curves (AUC) were also calculated
(Supplementary Table S4). The AUC of peanut and Ara h 2 sIgE were 0.735
and 0.829 in patients with a previous history of immediate reactions and
0.673 and 0.899 in patients without a history, respectively.
We also developed fitted probability curves for patients with and
without a previous history of immediate reactions (Figure 1). The 95%
PPV for peanut and Ara h 2 sIgE levels were 96.3 and 38.4
kUA/L in patients with a previous history of immediate
reactions, whereas those in patients without a history could not be
obtained. However, the 5% PPV for peanut and Ara h 2 sIgE levels were
0.70 and 0.23 kUA/L in patients without a previous
history of immediate reactions, respectively, whereas those in patients
with a history could not be obtained (Table 1).
In this study, we found that the presence of a previous history of
immediate reactions changed PPV for a peanut allergy.
In patients with a previous history of immediate reactions, peanut and
Ara h 2 sIgE levels higher than 96.3 kUA/L and 38.4
kUA/L, respectively, were correlated to a high
likelihood of positive OFC results. These patients may not need OFC to
be diagnosed with peanut allergy. On the other hand, we could not
calculate the 5% PPV, therefore patients with a previous history of
immediate reactions should undergo an OFC even if their specific IgE
levels are low. Especially we should mind that approximately 20% of
patients with a negative Ara h 2 sIgE developed symptoms in OFC in our
fitted probability curve.
In patients without a previous history of immediate reactions, we could
not calculate the 95% PPV. Peanut sIgE and Ara h 2 sIgE levels lower
than 0.70 kUA/L and 0.23 kUA/L,
respectively, are correlated to a high chance of ingesting peanuts
without experiencing symptoms. These patients may not need an OFC and
they may try consuming peanuts in their diets. In our fitted probability
curve, more than half of patients without a previous history of
immediate reactions to peanuts had negative OFC even if they had 100
kUA/L of peanut sIgE. Therefore, in patients without a
previous history of immediate reactions to peanuts, high levels of
peanut sIgE alone should not lead to avoiding peanuts and testing for
Ara h 2 sIgE levels is useful in determining whether to undergo peanut
OFC. Using the above information, we can assess a patient suspected of
peanut allergy with a flowchart (Supplementary Figure S2).
Peters et al. have reported the probability for a positive peanut
food challenge, by peanut sIgE and Ara h 2 sIgE.8 In
the study, although OFCs were performed with 6 g of peanuts and the
ratio of patients with a history of immediate reactions to peanuts was
not described, the 95% PPV of peanut and Ara h 2 sIgE was 87.9
kUA/L and 42.2 kUA/L, respectively.
These values were similar to the results of our study. One Australian
study found that 95% PPV of peanut sIgE to peanut allergy was 1.0
kUA/L and 39 kUA/L with and without a
previous history of immediate reactions,
respectively.7 These PPVs were lower than those in our
study. The reasons for this difference were considered as follows.
First, 9 g of peanut was used for the OFC. Second, all participants were
1 year old while in our study the ages ranged from 1 to 17 years. It has
been reported that infants are more likely to have lower 95% PPVs than
children aged 2 or older.5 Considering that age may
influence PPVs, we developed fitted probability curves for patients
<6 years and those 6 years or older. There was no obvious
difference between these groups (Supplementary Figure S3).
This study has some limitations. First, although older children were
included, OFCs were open-challenge tests and not double-blind
placebo-controlled food challenge tests. Second, analysis of the skin
prick test could not be performed because only a small number of
participants underwent this test. Third, this study presented fitted
predictive probability curves for the positive outcome of a 3 g peanut
OFC. These probability curves should not be used for predicting results
of OFC using >3 g of peanuts. Finally, potential risks of
bias and limitations related to the retrospective study design cannot be
ruled out.
In conclusion, a previous history of immediate reactions changes the
predictive accuracy for peanut allergy in children. The presence of a
previous history of immediate reactions should be considered when
performing OFC.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank Editage
(www.editage.com) for assistance
in English language editing.